Comments

To comment E-mail us at thegeorgetalk@gmail.com Thanks!
check out our neat surveys and become a follower (below, right)

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Rich's round table


Who is the real deal in San Fran?

Colin Kaepernick or Alex Smith?

Both are pretty good, but I think Kaepernick can run faster, might be a little better passer and could fit in as a respected leader of the team.

While it might be too early to really tell who will be the future QB of the 49rs long term, I for one think we need to let this guy  Kaepernick prove his point. He has been doing nothing but that every time he has a chance to play. I give mad props to Coach Jim Harbaugh for having major Cojones and making this move, while not really worrying about any fallen backlash from the fans or the media.

Let’s see the comparison between Smith and Kaepernick:

Kaepernick                                                         Smith 2011-12
Sunday

Comp pct - 64.0                                                 Comp pct  - 64.2

Pass YPG - 231                                                   Pass YPG  - 195.0

TD-Int ratio - 1.0                                               TD-Int ratio  - 3.0

For the season, Kaepernick is 11-for-18 with three touchdowns and no interceptions on his outside-the-pocket throws. Smith is 9-for-19 on such throws with one touchdown and one interception.

The big difference between the two is that Kaepernick still has a lot of room to grow, and while I believe Smith is a worthy QB, the Kaepernick upside is apparent.

-Rich Handy is a guest columnist for George Talk
 
 
Thanks Mr. H-
George